The balance after that averred that is a fit out-of an effective municipal character into the security; the matter in dispute exceeded, exclusive of can cost you, the sum of the five thousand dollars, and you may emerged within the Constitution or rules of one’s You, which there is certainly in addition a controversy ranging from people of various States

This new prayer is so it was adjudged and you will decreed you to definitely the said conditions known as the tax incorporated from inside the said work regarding Congress passed August step 1, 1894, is unconstitutional, null, and emptiness; that defendants become restrained of voluntarily complying to the conditions of said operate and you can making the directories, output, and statements significantly more than described, otherwise make payment on income tax aforesaid, and standard rescue.